• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Bedfordshire
  • Milton Keynes
  • Northamptonshire
  • Awards
  • Knowledge Hub
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
    • Sustainability
    • The Podcast
    • ATB TV
All Things Business

All Things Business

First For Local UK Business News

  • Education
  • Professional Services
    • Legal
    • Finance
    • Recruitment & HR
    • Creative Marketing
  • Property
  • Environment
    • Wellbeing
  • Industry
    • Industry
    • Manufacturing
    • Motors
    • Logistics
    • Technology
  • Events
    • Events
    • Food & Drink
    • Sport
  • News

Re-pricing of employee share options: grasp the opportunity

Finance, News | February 1, 2021

share opportunities hewitsons

Successive governments have, over the last 20 years, encouraged businesses of all sizes to offer their employees a stake in their success. The concept of granting options is now widely accepted with the prospect of a future reward helping to ensure that staff or key employees have a clear motivation to remain with and grow the business.

In any economic downturn, the impact on the financial performance and prospects of the business can significantly reduce its value and the value of the share options held by employees. 

Where the depressed value is such that the options are ‘underwater’, namely where exercise price for the share option is less than the value of the share itself, or where the options are subject to performance conditions which are now hopelessly optimistic, the perceived benefit of the options is at best heavily diluted.

Many companies should then consider modifying the share options to reflect the new circumstances to restore the perceived value.

For some companies, the effect on their valuation may be temporary. For others, the effect will be more permanent, whether by reason of a higher level of debt on its balance sheet or as a consequence of structural changes in their business sector which will need a new strategic approach.  

In the latter case, re-energising employees to fully engage in the new strategy could be particularly important. Where share options do not have any tax-advantaged status, then a re-pricing of existing options, coupled perhaps with new options with performance conditions, is fairly straightforward to achieve.

For option schemes which do carry tax advantages, notably Enterprise Management Incentives (EMI), re-pricing existing options to reflect the reduced valuation of the company will result in the loss of the tax advantages. Accordingly, it will usually be achieved by the surrender of the existing options and the re-grant of new options at a lower exercise price.

For EMI options, this will generally be permitted, provided that the employee does not hold unexercised EMI options over shares with an unrestricted market value (when granted) of more than £250,000 and has not been granted EMI options over shares with a value of £250,000 in the previous three years (the three-year rule). It is not often that this is the case.

If an employee holds options over shares with an unrestricted value of £249,999, then it is possible to surrender all of those options and re-grant new options up to that £250,000 limit. This does not offend the three-year rule. 

This can be particularly beneficial for a key manager who has been granted EMI options up to £249,999 and additionally holds non-EMI qualifying options. Where the value of the shares has diminished since the date the EMI options were granted, it should be possible to convert the non-qualifying options into EMI options. 

The tax advantages would be significant: under current rules (and let’s keep our fingers crossed) any gain on EMI options would be taxed at 10%, whereas non-qualifying options are subject to income tax and NICs with a potential overall tax rate of close on 53%.

A surrender and re-grant of options would also be appropriate where a company with venture capital or other external investors is raising new equity at a reduced valuation to the previous funding round. Re-granting by reference to that reduced valuation would maintain the positive impact for employees.

Where re-granting tax-advantaged options is not feasible, then another possibility to consider is the issue of shares to key employees at a time when the market value of those shares will hopefully be at its lowest.

Whilst in the current climate many employees are content to be in work, it would be complacent to assume that something more attractive will not present itself, and leaving re-pricing to a later date when valuations are then on the rise would miss the window of opportunity.

James Lawrence is head of the corporate finance team in Cambridge and specialises in the design and implementation of employee share schemes. 

For more information visit www.hewitsons.co.uk

James Lawrence Partner Hewitsons LLP

Northamptonshire

Related stories

  • Northamptonshire
    May 26, 2022

    Planning application for saints’ new high performance centre approved

    Northampton Saints are delighted to confirm that West Northamptonshire Council Planning Authority have approved the Club’s application for the construction of a…
  • East Hunsbury Primary School Northamptonshire
    May 26, 2022

    New Headteacher for East Hunsbury Primary School as tributes are paid to retiring Head after 21 years’ service

    “Be kind, work hard, believe” – that is the message to children at East Hunsbury Primary School from new Headteacher Kathryn Pennington,…
  • Windfall tax on energy companies: Chancellor and business secretary need to stand their ground against the windfall tax siren calls – MHA comments Northamptonshire
    May 23, 2022

    Windfall tax on energy companies: Chancellor and business secretary need to stand their ground against the windfall tax siren calls – MHA comments

    Following the growing calls to impose a windfall tax on the profits of energy companies, to address the cost of living crisis,…

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Stay up to date on All Things Business

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to receive the latest business news.

Online Edition

Northamptonshire edition, click here
Milton Keynes edition, click here
Bedfordshire edition, click here

Most Read

  • Howes Percival A trio of new partners in East Mids among five senior promotions
  • East Hunsbury Primary School New Headteacher for East Hunsbury Primary School as tributes are paid to retiring Head after 21 years’ service
  • centre:mk Centre:mk welcomes brand new Ted Baker store to Milton Keynes
  • Windfall tax on energy companies: Chancellor and business secretary need to stand their ground against the windfall tax siren calls – MHA comments Windfall tax on energy companies: Chancellor and business secretary need to stand their ground against the windfall tax siren calls – MHA comments
  • Workplace Wellbeing Why It's So Important Workplace Wellbeing: Why it’s so important

Footer

REGIONS

Northamptonshire
Milton Keynes
Bedfordshire
 

COMPANY

About Us
Contact
Awards
Podcast
Knowledge Hub
Sustainability
Request A Copy

Northamptonshire Office

1 Queensbridge, Northampton
NN4 7BF
Tel: 01604 267677

Milton Keynes and Bedfordshire Office

The Pinnacle, 170 Midsummer Boulevard, Milton Keynes,
MK9 1BP
Tel: 01908 030688

London Office

25 Bedford Square
London
WC1B 3HH
Tel: 0208 1760176

Follow us on

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

All Things Business is a publication produced by All Things Management Ltd. Registered in England No. 9590677


Privacy Policy