• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Bedfordshire
  • Milton Keynes
  • Northamptonshire
  • Awards
  • Knowledge Hub
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
    • Sustainability
    • The Podcast
    • ATB TV
All Things Business

All Things Business

First For Local UK Business News

  • Education
  • Professional Services
    • Legal
    • Finance
    • Recruitment & HR
    • Creative Marketing
  • Property
  • Environment
    • Wellbeing
  • Industry
    • Industry
    • Manufacturing
    • Motors
    • Logistics
    • Technology
  • Events
    • Events
    • Food & Drink
    • Sport
  • News

Ban on religious dress upheld in court

Legal, News | September 1, 2021

Savanita Atwal

A recent ruling by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) held that an employer can have a neutral dress policy preventing workers from wearing any political, philosophical or religious signs.

In Achbita v G4S Secure Solutions, the employer had a neutral dress policy in place. This meant that employees were not able to wear anything that had any political, religious or similar signs in any of their customer-facing roles. A Muslim employee working in a client-facing role was warned that she could not wear her headscarf whilst carrying out her role, she continued to do so despite the warnings, as a result the employee was dismissed.

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) considered whether the employer’s neutral dress policy amounted to direct discrimination on the grounds of religion. It was decided that as the policy prohibited all religious signs it did not treat one religion less favourably as against another and so the ECJ said this did not amount to direct discrimination.

The policy did, however, result in a difference in treatment which the ECJ held was indirectly discriminatory based on religion. This is because Muslims are placed at a particular disadvantage compared to other religions that do not wear religious dress.

A genuine need

In the case of IX v WABE, the ECJ ruled that such a ban can only be justified if the employer can provide a genuine need for the policy (a simple desire for neutrality is not sufficient), in line with the Framework Directive. For example, IX worked with children and their parents in an educational setting, so it is reasonable that parents may wish to have their children supervised by people who don’t openly display an affiliation with any particular religion or belief. A policy like this must also be applied ‘in a general and undifferentiated way’ to all manifestations of such beliefs, rather than prejudicing a particular group unnecessarily.

The implications for European and UK employers

The ECJ stated that the ruling allows courts in the EU’s 27 member states ‘a margin of discretion’ to decide whether a ban on religious symbols is justified, based on the laws they have in place to govern such matters. For example, wearing a headscarf was outlawed in French educational settings in 2004, while a ban on full-face coverings outside the home (such as a burqa or niqab) followed in 2011.

Due to Brexit, however, the judgment has no binding impact on British courts and tribunals. Even so, under Section 6(1) of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018, the UK justice system may ‘have regard’ to decisions made by the ECJ ‘so far as it is relevant to any matter before the court or tribunal’.

For further information regarding the above, contact a member of the Woodfines Employment Team at employmentlaw@woodfines.co.uk or call 0344 967 2505

Milton Keynes

Related stories

  • Lambert Smith Hampton's Raja Saleem Milton Keynes
    July 1, 2022

    A team to guide you through every stage

    Our experienced Building Consultancy team of chartered building surveyors and project managers operates across and throughout the UK. We work with developers,…
  • Milton Keynes College Milton Keynes
    July 1, 2022

    New hi-tech business centre boasts fabulous facilities

    Companies facing skills shortages can now turn to Milton Keynes College for even greater support thanks to the opening of a new…
  • Plumbing and Gas Solutions Milton Keynes
    July 1, 2022

    Strategic changes to drive service to the next level

    With the foundations of a successful business well and truly laid, Milton Keynes-based Plumbing and Gas Solutions is currently implementing strategic changes…

Primary Sidebar

Stay up to date on All Things Business

Get the latest business round ups, stories and ATB podcasts delivered straight to your inbox.

All Things Business Podcast

Online Edition

Northamptonshire edition, click here
Milton Keynes edition, click here
Bedfordshire edition, click here

Most Read

  • Plumbing and Gas Solutions Strategic changes to drive service to the next level
  • Scott Norville Setbacks prove challenging for lease firm and its clients
  • Avery Creative Motivation to find the courage to make changes
  • Eddisons Eddisons makes £1.8m property agency acquisition, strengthening Midlands operation
  • WSA The Communications Agency Proud to branch out, but never forgetting our roots

Footer

REGIONS

Northamptonshire
Milton Keynes
Bedfordshire
 

COMPANY

About Us
Contact
Awards
Podcast
Knowledge Hub
Sustainability
Request A Copy

Northamptonshire Office

1 Queensbridge, Northampton
NN4 7BF
Tel: 01604 267677

Milton Keynes and Bedfordshire Office

The Pinnacle, 170 Midsummer Boulevard, Milton Keynes,
MK9 1BP
Tel: 01908 030688

London Office

25 Bedford Square
London
WC1B 3HH
Tel: 0208 1760176

Follow us on

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

All Things Business is a publication produced by All Things Management Ltd. Registered in England No. 9590677


Privacy Policy