• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Bedfordshire
  • Milton Keynes
  • Northamptonshire
  • Awards
  • Knowledge Hub
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
    • Sustainability
    • The Podcast
    • ATB TV
All Things Business

All Things Business

First For Local UK Business News

  • Education
  • Professional Services
    • Legal
    • Finance
    • Recruitment & HR
    • Creative Marketing
  • Property
  • Environment
    • Wellbeing
  • Industry
    • Industry
    • Manufacturing
    • Motors
    • Logistics
    • Technology
  • Events
    • Events
    • Food & Drink
    • Sport
  • News

Convenient and quicker – but at what cost?

Legal, News | December 1, 2021

Syvil Morris

Criminal law solicitors who are used to being called out in the dead of night, for alleged crimes great and small, and commercial litigation solicitors who are well used to closing mega-deals, which require the midnight oil to be burned, will probably not have much sympathy with the recent experiences of us family lawyers! 

One of the legacies of COVID-19 has meant that more and more hearings are taking place online or over the telephone, and they are going on for longer and longer past the ‘normal time’ of 4.30pm. More and more non-urgent hearings are even starting after 4.30pm. This spate of anti-social family law litigation hours, over the last year or so, has led one judge to describe the issue as being ‘endemic’ in routine applications. A variety of reasons can be cited for this, but perhaps the least unsurprising one is that family lawyers like to talk. Indeed we do!

On a serious note, although online hearings are convenient and allow the court to at least manage in a meaningful way the ever-increasing backlog of work caused by the pandemic, they are extremely impersonal and they lack gravitas. Online hearings also tend to be quicker. It is the combination of the former and an effect of the latter that has led some lay parties and some professional representatives alike to feel that the matters are not being taken seriously. 

This probably doesn’t have too much of an impact on litigants who are dealing with genuinely routine matters such as, for example, arranging for statements to be filed and served. But what about single mothers who face the prospect of their children being removed from their care, whilst watching the tiny screen of a mobile phone in their kitchen? Sometimes insult is added to injury by the fact that the very children who are to be removed can be heard playing in the home. In those circumstances one of the most obvious ways of countering the almost inevitable feeling of injustice is to make long and detailed submissions, sometimes repeatedly, to underline and highlight important points. 

It is not always possible to make ‘careful and analytical’ written submissions, and in any event clients actually want to hear their cases being articulated, especially the strongest points and also the more nuanced ones.

The wellbeing of family lawyers and judges has rightly taken centre stage in recent months, but it is also important to think of the wellbeing of litigants, not all of whom are professionally represented. So, the ‘two-way street’ that one judge has made reference to recently is actually a ‘three-way street’. The President of the Law Society of England and Wales recently made a similar point, stating that ‘access to justice must be the principal consideration when deciding if remote hearings can be fairly conducted in the family courts’.

This is even more important given the ‘monumental decisions’ that these courts have to make, involving rights such as the Right to Family Life and the Right to a Fair Hearing.

Women who are at risk of having their children removed from their care are often, by definition, vulnerable – sometimes the most vulnerable in society. Also, they are sometimes the victims of physical and emotional abuse as well as sexual and financial abuse. All of this may be exacerbated by relationship issues arising from substance abuse and mental health issues. 

A moment’s reflection will highlight the risk of such mothers actually being revictimised by a hearing which is at once impersonal and speedy and which may be characterised by lightness and frivolity. That is not to say that remote hearings have not found a suitable place in the family justice system; it’s just that they shouldn’t be allowed to become the norm. 

Find out more about Bastian Lloyd Morrisor call 01908 546580

Syvil Lloyd Morris

Solicitor Advocate and Co-founder

Bastian Lloyd Morris

 

Milton Keynes

Related stories

  • MPs celebrate city status announcement Milton Keynes
    May 20, 2022

    MPs celebrate city status announcement

    MPs Iain Stewart and Ben Everitt have shared their delight as Milton Keynes was finally officially awarded city status as part of…
  • centre:mk Milton Keynes
    May 17, 2022

    Centre:mk welcomes brand new Ted Baker store to Milton Keynes

    centre:mk are pleased to announce the addition of global lifestyle brand, Ted Baker, to their store line-up in Milton Keynes later this…
  • MK Gateway Milton Keynes
    May 10, 2022

    Taking centre stage at real estate forum

    On 17-19 May, the Socius team will join over 4,000 attendees in Leeds for the annual UKREiiF event, which connects people, places…

Primary Sidebar

Stay up to date on All Things Business

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to receive the latest business news.

Online Edition

Northamptonshire edition, click here
Milton Keynes edition, click here
Bedfordshire edition, click here

Most Read

  • East Hunsbury Primary School New Headteacher for East Hunsbury Primary School as tributes are paid to retiring Head after 21 years’ service
  • Howes Percival A trio of new partners in East Mids among five senior promotions
  • centre:mk Centre:mk welcomes brand new Ted Baker store to Milton Keynes
  • Windfall tax on energy companies: Chancellor and business secretary need to stand their ground against the windfall tax siren calls – MHA comments Windfall tax on energy companies: Chancellor and business secretary need to stand their ground against the windfall tax siren calls – MHA comments
  • Workplace Wellbeing Why It's So Important Workplace Wellbeing: Why it’s so important

Footer

REGIONS

Northamptonshire
Milton Keynes
Bedfordshire
 

COMPANY

About Us
Contact
Awards
Podcast
Knowledge Hub
Sustainability
Request A Copy

Northamptonshire Office

1 Queensbridge, Northampton
NN4 7BF
Tel: 01604 267677

Milton Keynes and Bedfordshire Office

The Pinnacle, 170 Midsummer Boulevard, Milton Keynes,
MK9 1BP
Tel: 01908 030688

London Office

25 Bedford Square
London
WC1B 3HH
Tel: 0208 1760176

Follow us on

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

All Things Business is a publication produced by All Things Management Ltd. Registered in England No. 9590677


Privacy Policy